General Wedding Planning Topics
Cat:336d8010-1fcd-4410-9356-c39e985527ec
Need clarity...
Wedding Drama
Need clarity...
<font color="#ffffff">Your future mother-in-law said what?! Got a sticky situation? Get advice on friends, family, and more!</font>
Ok, I am writing because I do not know if my feelings are justified or if I am being irrational.&nbsp; I am hormonal and super sensitive, so I would not put it past me to be irrational.&nbsp; Here is
0
False
Wedding Drama
Need clarity...
<font color="#ffffff">Your future mother-in-law said what?! Got a sticky situation? Get advice on friends, family, and more!</font>
Ok, I am writing because I do not know if my feelings are justified or if I am being irrational.&nbsp; I am hormonal and super sensitive, so I would not put it past me to be irrational.&nbsp; Here is
0
Cat:336d8010-1fcd-4410-9356-c39e985527ecForum:8b0ecf40-d82c-4dd4-a709-f775574bfa5c
Cat:336d8010-1fcd-4410-9356-c39e985527ecForum:8b0ecf40-d82c-4dd4-a709-f775574bfa5cDiscussion:1aac018d-e3a1-4af7-b7cc-7f49f8b413e2
You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register
 

Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 7:10 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-10-2007
ATLANTA
908357887507521
Posts: 182
First: 8/10/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


Ok, I am writing because I do not know if my feelings are justified or if I am being irrational.  I am hormonal and super sensitive, so I would not put it past me to be irrational.  Here is the situation, let me know what you think:

My long time best friend from grade school got engaged last January to be wed in Sept of the same year.  She asked me to be the MOH and I readily agreed.  Things were arranged poorly and she ended up moving the date to May 2010.  In August, my FH proposed and we immediately set a date (he is military and up for orders so we needed to get the ball rolling) for Jan 2010. 

Fast forward three months.  My wedding is in less than 80 days and my FH and I are contributing about 50% of the wedding while my family has graciously agreed to help us.  My friend's family, as well as her FH's family, are taking care of theirs.  I am really happy for her, esp since I know she recently bought a new house with FH.  The point is, I do not think she realizes how people who do not make 6 figures budget.

My issue is that, with 6 months to go, she wants us to order the dresses for the wedding all at the same time.  I am not as upset with the fact that I have never tried the dress on (I already know I will look like a balloon in the dress, I am apple shape with big tatas and she tried it on and loved it as a size 0- the dress has no shape).  What I have a problem with is having to pay for everything right this second when I am broke as it is trying to pay for my wedding.  She wants us to all order them at the same time so they will be from the same dye lot.  It is a black dress...  I have no problem getting fitted or whatever (even though I know alterations will be needed and those will be extra) because I am never the same size from month to month, but no big deal.  I am just having a hard time forking over $160+ all at one time (the dress will not be ordered until payment is received in full).

Am I being unreasonable?  We have 6 months until her wedding.  I understand that she wants to get it done and check things off her list.  I completely get it.  I am just a little frustrated and things are getting expensive.  Should I just let her know that I just can't put that much money into her wedding right now, or just suck it up.  She just got the dress to be in my wedding, so I feel a little bad about it, but we all went together to get those and she could order it when she had payment or could finance.  There are no layaway or payment options here...

Please let me know if I am justified or just need to take a midol and get over myself...

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 7:28 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-10-2007
ATLANTA
908357887507521
Posts: 182
First: 8/10/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


P.S. Another of her bridesmaids found the dress for half the price online, but she rejected the idea because she heard (from a dress shop) that the dresses online were rejected by the manufactures and the dye lots were not the same.

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 7:29 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
06-16-2009
LANSING
4321807391366757
Posts: 882
First: 6/16/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


You should talk to her and let her know that by ordering this dress now will cause a financial hardship on you. Give her a date that you will order by.

If she is a really good friend, she should understand. And, IMO, if she wants the dress ordered now that badly, then she can maybe front the money herself.

But I don't think you are overreacting. Talk to her and let her know what's up.

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 7:40 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-10-2007
ATLANTA
908357887507521
Posts: 182
First: 8/10/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


I know I need to talk to her regardless.  I am a little nervous because I know that she is pretty determined to get this done NOW, but hopefully we can work this out.  Thanks misma.

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 9:02 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-23-2009
8408683017551421
Posts: 235
First: 5/14/2009

Last: 11/16/2009


Not to make waves, but...

What's wrong with using a credit card for this purchase?? You can pay a little bit at a time and pay it off over time that way. I know credit cards are *evil* but it is these situations in which they are handy and so long as you are responsible, using a credit card should be no issue.

If a credit card is out of the question and you are unable to take on the financial burden of being a bridesmaid - regardless of excuses - you should consider talking to the bride about stepping down from your "post" due to the financial strain. It's not fair to her to put the financial burden on her because you cannot handle it. Then if she offers to loan you the money, let her know that you appreciate it and be sure to give her money for it as you get it.

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 9:08 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-10-2007
ATLANTA
908357887507521
Posts: 182
First: 8/10/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


I do not think credit cards are evil.  In fact, I have been trying to pay them off for the last two years.  I am also paying down student loans.  I refuse to use credit cards for my own wedding because I feel it would be counter productive to what I have been trying to do for the last several years.  I thank you for your advice, kitkat, but I do not think putting myself in debt further is the answer.  I have no problem with layaway or even getting the dress in Feb for her May wedding.  I will probably just have to talk to her as misma said and try to work something out.

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 9:19 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
10-30-2004
BOSTON
981246950001257
Posts: 1014
First: 5/8/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


That whole dye lot thing is a load of hooey.  But trying to convince your friend of it probably isn't worth the time or breath. 

Just tell her that you can't afford the dress right now.  Give her 2 options: 1. you will order the dress by X date [date when you will have the $] or 2. you order the dress now, she pays the $ and you pay her back when you do have the money, w/ a drop dead date for repayment.

Having her front the money is not unreasonable b/c she is being silly w/ wanting the dresses ordered this soon and b/c of the whole 'dye lot' issue. 

I paid for my BM's dresses b/c I didn't want them to have to shell out [2 sisters - one laid off and the other getting married 11 weeks after me; and my best friend MOH who is a teacher and doesn't make alot]. Our dresses cost $160 as well. I considered it my gift to them.  I think they appreciated it more than a tote or other silly BM gift. I also did get them individual  gifts geared to their taste as a thank you. ;-)  It's possible that you friend may decide that the dress is her thank you present to you once you tell her you are in a financial bind.  A true friend will understand.  Good luck!

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 9:21 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
07-24-2008
BOSTON
5806524874383125
Posts: 597
First: 5/8/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


I don't think you're being unreasonable, RebMik. There's no good reason why the dresses NEED to be ordered six months ahead of time, especially since it's not like black is a seasonal color that might not be available later. In fact, you might want to frame it to her that it would be easier for everyone to wait until February (after the holidays, maybe people will have gotten their tax refunds, etc.). I know I'm always strapped for cash at this time of year -- and I'm not getting married in January!


I think if those are primary reasons, it won't make her feel like your wedding is the problem, but that it's just more sensible for everyone involved. People always forget what a strain the holidays are on the pocketbook until we're up to our necks in them again.


(Btw, I applaud your dedication to fiscal responsibility. While I get KitKat's point about credit cards being a useful option, I've been bitten already by credit card companies deciding to randomly more than DOUBLE my interest rate for NO reason recently. So, while I used to be an excellent customer for them, using my card regularly, paying it off religiously, now it's definitely not what's in my wallet on principle alone. I use debit almost exclusively, except for one teeny-tiny purchase every month to keep my accounts current.)

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 9:23 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-10-2007
ATLANTA
908357887507521
Posts: 182
First: 8/10/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


Thanks, alf and ariel.  I agree about the dye lot, and I thought maybe she wanted them ordered right away because they might be going out of season, but it turns out they are just coming out this coming year (2010).  I will definitely need to talk to her.  We have been friends a long time and I want to be a part of her day, but dropping that kind of cask all at once is just not possible at the moment.  I appreciate the advice.

Ariel, it is hard to stay on top of credit card payments!  I was in school for 6 years (undergrad and grad school) and even though I worked several part time jobs, the expenses required the cc...  I am now paying dearly for it...  Regardless, I am trying really hard to be responsible.  I do not want further debt to cloud my first few years of married life. 

I thank you all for your advice.

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 9:25 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
06-20-2006
BOSTON
35626637508267
Posts: 713
First: 5/14/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


RebMik, I totally disagree with KitKat's tone.  "not being fair to your friend, putting the financial burden on her...blah blah blah".

First of all, she's your very best friend.  If it were me and my BFF, I'd just say, I'm sorry Judy, I can't afford to pay the entire $160 right now.  I can pay $80.  Can you front me the other $80 and I'll pay you back.  If she can't, I would just charge it.  You can't put a tiny price (the interest charges) on your friendship. 

She probably read that dye lot crap in a bride's magazine or something.   It might matter if your dresses were maroon, but not black!  But, let it go.  In the end, she's your BFF, a rare and valuable thing in the world today.   Good luck! 

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 9:33 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-10-2007
ATLANTA
908357887507521
Posts: 182
First: 8/10/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


Thanks cosmo.  Interest rates suck!  I agree that I do not want this to hurt our friendship, esp with over 10 years under our belts!  I'll just have to find out what she says when I talk to her.

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 10:23 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
07-24-2008
BOSTON
5806524874383125
Posts: 597
First: 5/8/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


Stick to it -- the day you pay off that last card is completely worth the hard work to get there. I (finally) paid off my first new car in September and last month I almost tried to send them another check! It's like, wow, I can't believe I finally have this monkey off my back. Felt the same way when I was finally done with my credit card balances.


None of that is to say I'm done with debt forever. I'm sure I won't be. But if the timing had been different and I were still paying off school debts with the credit card company decided to send my rate through the roof, I don't know what I would have done. So sinister.

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 10:39 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-10-2007
ATLANTA
908357887507521
Posts: 182
First: 8/10/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


It is really hateful!  It is like they WANT you to be in their control forever!  I am lucky that mine have not tried to screw me-yet (and "yet" is the operative word). I have already paid down a little more than 4500 and every time that 1,000th place changes on the statement, I breath a small sigh of relief.  Only 5,000 more to go!  Holp crap...

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 10:41 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
08-15-2008
NEW HAMPSHIRE
5451543958318906
Posts: 932
First: 6/19/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


    The info about the dye lots of on-line dresses may be true, since that is part of why many times a distributor will sell particular lots of dresses to different outlets that will not have ones in a shop people can compare them to, or buy some samples and have ones ordered not match.

    However, the flip side of that is that they do Quality Control  to make sure dresses ordered from shops even several  months apart will all be matching.

     Friend bride  does not NEED to do this now- it is a convenience to do something early that could easily be done later - you have a less flexible situation. 
     Asking her to front half the money is one compromise. 

      Another is to have everyone else order, and have you as MOH perhaps order the same thing later, or buy an off the rack different dress in Feb or March  that is compatible with theirs, of enough different style  or material to distinguish you as MOH not one of bms.
     That yours could then be a style that flatters your figure type, would be an all around plus.  You will like it better, and the wp in general (and pictures) looks better when each woman is in something flattering.

     The bride might worry if no one has dresses until very close.  
Knowing the group does, and only one dress that convention says may differ as MOH dress,   needs to be bought off the rack -  this should ease her mind.

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 11:04 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
08-03-2009
BALTIMORE
9503848837582757
Posts: 313
First: 8/3/2009

Last: 11/18/2009


If she is a friend, which i am not doubting, she should understand where your coming from if you say to her, "hey look, i can't get it right now, i'm broke, can i wait a little longer to get mine? I'm sorry that they won't be dyed together".  If she offeres to help or comes up with a solution that will work with you, then good, if not, she'll have to deal. No one can come up with money they don't have, and if you are paying off debt right now, the last thing i would suggest is to rack up more.

Just make sure she knows that her feelings about this are important to you and assure her that you do want to be a part of the wedding, and just see where the convo goes from there.

I'm sure you love your friend even when she has her moments. Yes, she is being a little picky about the dye stuff, but...it's not the end of the world either was and i have faith that you two can compromise and work it out somehow. Especially since you understand first hand what she is going through with wedding planning.

Good luck :)

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 2:28 PM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-10-2007
ATLANTA
908357887507521
Posts: 182
First: 8/10/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


Thanks ladies for your comments.  I will try to talk to her.  She wants to meet within the next few days so everyone can get measured and pay.  I'll have to give her a call and hopefully we can straighten things out.  I appreciate the advice!

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/4/2009 4:41 PM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
02-04-2008
ST. LOUIS
8521377378392343
Posts: 1071
First: 5/9/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


Reb, I'm coming into this discussion late but here are my thoughts. 

If you can't afford to purchase the dress right now tell her.  She can either offer to pay for the dress until you reimburse her OR you can always tell her you can't afford to be in her wedding. 

One of my bridesmaids really couldn't afford to be in the wedding but she never told me. I didn't find out until it was too late.  If she would have told me it was a hardship for her I would have told her if she needed to drop out it was completely understandable.

I couldn't afford to pay for one bridesmaids dress without feeling like I should pay for all of them and I couldn't afford that.

As it was I did cover the cost of her dress and she paid me back but paying me back was still a hardship.

My suggestion is to be honest with your friend and see what solutions she has to offer.  

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/11/2009 1:48 PM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
01-10-2007
ATLANTA
908357887507521
Posts: 182
First: 8/10/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


Just an update.  I talked to my friend and she was pretty cool about it.  She still wants us all to order the dresses at the same time for the dye lot "issue," but agreed to help out with paying with it if we need to go that route.  She also called the dress shop owner that is getting the dresses ordered and talked her into allowing layaway or a payment plan since my friend has already put so much business into the shop (bought her dress and MOB dress there; also her FMIL has been good friends with the owner for a long time).  Thanks again for the advice!  Just needed a little courage to get it done. 

Re: Need clarity...

posted at 11/12/2009 11:19 AM CST on weddingchannel.com
Joined on
05-05-2009
NEW JERSEY
5688771290288270
Posts: 18
First: 6/30/2009

Last: 11/20/2009


Glad everything worked out, I knew she would understand. Heck, I asked my girls to buy their dresses with 15 months to go because the color I liked was being discontinued. I did offer to pay if it was needed.

My Viewing Preferences

Show user signatures
Sort by most recent post
Home | Planning Tools | Ideas & Advice | Wedding Gowns | Local Wedding Vendors | Wedding Registry Center | Wedding Gift Store | Community | Wedding Websites I Privacy Policy Terms of Use | Newsletters | Advertise With Us | Company Info | Survey | Guest Home | Order Status | CelebrityWeddingBuzz.com | MyDIYWeddingDay.com | TheKnot.com TheNest.com | ShopforWeddings.com | WeddingTracker.com | TheBump.com | LilaGuide.com | Weddings.com | Weddingbook | Mommyhood | BreastFeeding.com | LilaGuide.com|PartySpot.com
© 1997-2009 WeddingChannel.com | HELP | Couples Directory | Site Map